Burrito Beach: Structuring a VC Investment
Improving Returns Through Deal Structure
Once the unit model is built, the investor must determine how much to pay for the opportunity and how to structure the deal. Burrito Beach introduces the valuation and term-structuring phase of the framework—APV, comparables, cap tables, and how deal terms affect investor returns.
Company
Burrito Beach
Industry
Fast-Casual Restaurant Chain
Key Frameworks
Phase 2a: Valuation
Having completed the unit model (Chapters 3–5), the methodology now turns to valuation and deal structure. The sequence:
- APV (Adjusted Present Value): Value the enterprise based on discounted unit-level free cash flows, adjusted for the probability of success and the tax shield of debt.
- Probability-Adjusted APV: Weight the APV by the likelihood of reaching the projected scale—acknowledging that most early-stage companies do not reach full roll-out.
- Comparables Method: Triangulate against similar public companies or recent private transactions to sanity-check the APV valuation.
- Term Sheet: Document the agreed-upon economics of the investment—valuation, preference stack, board structure, anti-dilution provisions.
- Capitalization Table: Model the equity split across founders, investors, and option pool across multiple funding rounds.
- IRR/CoC Table of Returns: Stress-test the investment across different exit scenarios to understand the range of investor outcomes.
Burrito Beach
Burrito Beach is a fast-casual Mexican food chain based in Chicago. This example uses a real venture capital investment to illustrate how deal structure—not just valuation—determines investor returns.
Key learning objectives:
- The difference between pre-money and post-money valuation: How a valuation headline number translates into actual ownership percentages.
- Preferred stock mechanics: How liquidation preferences, participation rights, and conversion features protect investors while incentivizing founders.
- The effect of dilution: How subsequent financing rounds affect earlier investors' ownership and return profiles.
- Structuring for downside protection: How terms like full-ratchet vs. weighted-average anti-dilution affect both parties in a down round.
IRR / CoC Table of Returns
The IRR/CoC table is a scenario matrix that shows investor returns across:
- Different exit valuations (2x, 3x, 5x, 10x of entry valuation)
- Different exit timing (3 years, 5 years, 7 years from investment)
- Different capital structures (common vs. preferred equity, with and without participation)
For each cell of the matrix, the table calculates:
- Multiple on invested capital (CoC / MOIC): Cash returned ÷ Cash invested
- Internal rate of return (IRR): Annualized return accounting for timing
The table makes the investment's risk/return profile transparent. A venture requiring $10M of capital that returns $50M in 5 years generates a 5x CoC and roughly a 38% IRR—above the typical 30–40% VC hurdle rate.